Tuesday, March 27, 2018

A Quick Thought: YouTube, The Discussion is Over

YouTube, once the haven for creative minds, an open space where one could create and share, has finally begun closing the last doors on that dream. Just this week, YouTube has rolled out new regulations restricting "gun" content on the site. Instead opening the door to discussion, they have closed it and has made it quite clear that there will be no debate.

To make it clear, gun channels aren't the only ones effected by YouTube's new regulations. These include both Liberal and Conservative channels that YouTube likely deems too controversial. It is clear that they are trying to push a new image, an image to attract advertisers. This isn't some giant conspiracy by the left or the right, it's about setting an image, and that image is one that is safe and makes them money.

Guns are their newest target line stretching back to their fist efforts to wipe out copyright infringement. The later was a noble goal, copyright is important to respect, but their efforts (and lack of oversight) often negatively effected reviewers who were covered by Fair Use (more on that at a later date). As for guns, the vast majority of these channels (which vary greatly in format) are enthusiasts, many provide education both in safety and history, not encouraging gun violence.

While the recent shooting in Florida is definitely the catalyst for this new assault on gun channels, again it is part of YouTube's rebranding. This effort is likely to be their downfall, when your try to build interest in your product, the last thing you should do is alienate your audience. Instead of working with these people, they've been branded, in essence, villains are and slowly being pushed off the boat.

One part of this new regulation prohibits links to sites that sell firearms. Many gun shops are small businesses, not large corporations like Google. Many don't just sell guns, but also provide education in gun safety, hunter courses, self-defense courses, and some even have indoor ranges. They also support sporting leagues and shooting competitions. I would encourage anyone to go to a gun store and inquire about the services they provide and you would be surprised about what actually goes on there.

However, YouTube will continue to alienate it's user base and kill the soul that once made it great. Other sites will rise up and fill the gap. They've made it quite clear, through their algorithms and inability to converse with the people who made them great in the first place, the discussion is over.

YouTube's new Policies:

https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/7667605?hl=en

Thursday, January 11, 2018

A New Year Reintroduction

It's  New Year, so let me reintroduce the blog the world...

Welcome to the "Mental Rambler", a blog were we discuss topics from religion and politics to video games and movies, and everything in between. Feel free to discuss the topics in the comments section or on the Facebook page; https://www.facebook.com/Blacksword4/ ; please be thoughtful and respectful with your comments.

This blog is opinion, I provide facts to back up those opinions, but please that in your mind while reading. My goal is to get people to think and consider other view points on a wide verity of topics. In this day and age of social media, it is important to think clearly and objectively, rather than letting your emotions run wild, and too often, that is is case on places like Facebook and Twitter.

I do apologize for the random schedule of posts, however with a full time job at my family's print shop; http://gatewayprinting.org/ , and a novel, the frequency of which I post is a bit... random... However, I should have at least one article posted per month.

Also, check out my art blog, "The Printed Rambler". I don't post there with the greatest frequency, there are some interesting topics there. I also plan to  start posting some of my photography there in the near future.
http://theprintedrambler.blogspot.com/

If your interested in more in depth discussion about film, check out the "The Movie Musers". A burgeoning YouTube channel started by me and some friends where talk about movies.
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCEwXnCkj7_s6ljBCi8bfDSA

Once Again, Welcome to the Mental Rambler and Happy New Year!

Saturday, November 11, 2017

Quick Thought: A Discussion On the Tolkien

“I do not love the bright sword for its sharpness, nor the arrow for its swiftness, nor the warrior for his glory. I love only that which they defend.” - J.R.R. Tolkien

The quote above is one of the more famous lines written by Tolkien in his writing. The meaning of the phrase, in simpler terms, is a love for a cause that someone stands up for, not the weapons with which they fight. One could  this attribute to a writer to stands up for a cause; "I do not love the pen for it's fineness, nor the computer for it's speed, nor the writer for his language, I love only that which they defend." A simple and easy to understand sentence, but with great depth and meaning.

However, recently a friend of mine called the quote "bull#*!@" in a conversation over my own fascination with the history warfare and weapons. Tolkien himself put great detail in his stories on the weapons used, giving them names and unique histories, and describing their connection to major characters. If you read the "Lord of the Rings", "The Silmarillion", or "The Hobbit", is the focus on the weapons or what they do with those weapons?

In those stories, the characters are defending their homes, friends, and loved ones against tyrannical foes who would destroy them or force them into slavery. We read about their acts of heroism in the face overwhelming odds, fighting for the freedom of others. We admire their weapons and their courage, and love what they fight for.

Tolkien fought in the First World War, in that war he probably saw horrors one couldn't imagine. He could admire the bravery that a soldier showed in the face of battle, or the technological advancement of the weapons; but love that they fought for their friends and a cause they believed in. When you think about that quote in that context, as well as his work as a whole, the quote's meaning comes to light. Just like Frodo and Sam marching through Mordor to save their home and loved ones, or Glorfindel defending his people from a balorg during the Fall of Gondolin. They did heroic deeds, but it was what they defended we love.

Tolkien's legendarium was clearly inspired by the horrors of World War I, not just his love of norse mythology. In his writing, the wars of Middle-Earth and Beleriand are not glorious, but bloody, disgusting, and horrifying, not glorifying battle. The weapons in his writing have names and descriptions, but that is to provide depth and history, his real focus is on the characters and their sacrifices, drawing inspiration from his wartime experience; the Fall of Gondolin, was written after fighting at the Battle of the Somme, and the "Dead Marshes" are directly inspired by battlefield in it's aftermath.

In my own opinion, this quote encompasses all of Tolkien's works, not a glorification of swords and battle, but a love of ones fellow man. Calling it "bull#*!@" is an act of ignorance and lack of understanding, the swords are part of the story, but they are not the meaning of the stories. However, we should also look at this quote along side another of his, perhaps encompassing the entirety of his world view; “If more of us valued food and cheer and song above hoarded gold, it would be a merrier world.”

References:


Monday, October 16, 2017

Is the Prime Directive Good or Terrible

Star Trek's "Prime Directive", also known as "Directive Number One", is one of, if not the most important rule within Starfleet and the Federation, in the series. The idea was that of noninterference with civilizations at a lesser state of cultural and technological development. It stems back to points in human history when interference by European cultures made contact with technologically less advanced cultures in the Americas with   results. As well as also being a way prevent the exploitation of those people for selfish means, such as resources and labor. Even in the modern day this is true, when a nation's belief in it's own morally superiority resulted in them forcing political and economic ideals on another nation without understanding its people's culture or history.

In the Next Generation episode, "Symbiosis", Picard (Patrick Stewart) is quoted; "The Prime Directive is not just a set of rules; it is a philosophy... and a very correct one. History has proven again and again that whenever mankind interferes with a less developed civilization, no matter how well intentioned that interference may be, the results are invariably disastrous" (Memory Alpha).

When Columbus came to the Americas in the 1400s, it set off a chain reaction that would result in war, disease, death, and enslavement of the native peoples.  The "Columbian Exchange" brought European diseases such as Smallpox, which the native people had no immunity to.  Eventually these colonies would rebel and win their freedom from Europe, but only after years of blood shed and death, and exploitation of their natural resources. In a modern example, our support of rebel forces opposed to Muammar Gaddafi during the Libyan Civil War resulted in a fracturing of the country and another civil war that has lasted since 2014. While trying to rid a country of a brutal dictator is a noble goal (though a root cause of the intervention was oil), but without an understanding of the culture, people, and history, you may be opening the proverbial "Pandora's box."

Probably the worst example of American interventionism, and the reason behind the "Prime Directive" was the Vietnam War. This was a war that was the result of our Cold War foreign policy to halt Communism and contain it. As a result, we fought a war that lasted over a decade, resulted in numerous atrocities on both sides, and caused the deaths of hundreds of thousands. With an understanding of the Vietnamese people's desire for freedom, as they had been subjugated for centuries by the Chinese, French, and Japanese, the war may have been avoided.

In the TNG episode "Justice", Picard is quoted saying, "There can be no justice so long as laws are absolute. Even life itself is an exercise in exceptions" (Memory Alpha). Indeed, the Prime Directive is not entirely absolute, exceptions have been made. In the TNG episode "Pen Pals", Data plays a distress signal  from an alien child whose home is threatened by a volcano. Because of that, Picard determines it can’t be ignored, and they interfere.

The Vietnam War, once again, is a great example of the merits of the rule, and the exemption. Asking for help is different than forcing help because you believe that you are morally, culturally, and technologically superior. What right do we have to enforce our ideas upon another people, even if we believe it will be beneficial?  Had the U.S. understood Ho Chi Minh's plea (he even read the preamble to the Declaration of Independence) and not  blinded by fear of Communism, and as a result backed the French, the outcome might have been different. Like in Japan after WW II, the U.S. could have provided equipment and economic support that may have helped create a more modern society. It would have prevented the ineffectual and corrupt program of "Pacification" in the South, and the brutal land reforms, that left thousands dead, in the north, as well as the war.

I have heard the idea of “what if” considered stupid, however, not considering the possibilities is a sign of ignorance. Taking risks is not bad and may yield beneficial results, but you should consider the consequences. You may help a Medieval level society cure a plague, but soon they may become dependent upon you. You can tech them how to prevent disease, but you have stunted their own technological and cultural growth. You may change their entire identity as a people, destroying a unique idea that may have come later in their history and benefited many. You may also give technology to a people who use it to commit acts of violence.

The "Prime Directive", like all human laws, is imperfect, but tries to curb human behavior that might be devastating if left unchecked, even if it is benevolent. Our history has countless examples of people being devastated as a result of human greed and ignorance. The worst example of this was known as "The White Man's Burden", creating the horrors of 19th Century Colonialism. The law is based on the idea that people have the right to determine their own destiny, should they ask for help, we provide to the extent they desire, and freedom of self-determination is the most sacred right of any human.

References:

http://memory-alpha.wikia.com/wiki/Prime_Directive

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prime_Directive

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Libyan_Civil_War_(2014%E2%80%93present)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Libyan_Civil_War_(2011)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vietnam_War

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Columbian_Exchange

Friday, October 6, 2017

Shootings & Gun Control

In every tragedy, we look at something to blame, we want something tangible to take our anger out on. After the Columbine Shooting in 1999, one of the scapegoats was the video game "Doom", a violent first person shooter (FPS) released in 1993. The perpetrators of the horrific crime were known fans of the game, and supposedly even created a custom .WAD file that was a complete layout of the school with the monsters modified to look like students (this turned out to be no more than a myth). Evidence would later reveal that bullying played a major role in their motivation, yet an inanimate object with no malicious intent was still blamed.

Why do we look to blame entertainment, guns, flags, ect... as the cause of these tragedies? My theory is that we humans don't want to look inward, we don't want to face the darker recesses of our minds, we want to pretend that, that side doesn't exist in most of us. We want to believe that an inanimate object influenced an action and removing that item will eliminate the threat. All that does is put a bandaid over the problem, banning guns might lower the statistics of gun violence, but it doesn't provide a cure.

The discussion of Gun Control shouldn't be looked at as a dirty one. The left needs to stop the "ban all guns" rhetoric and the right needs to stop the "don't take my guns" rhetoric. The result of those arguments being shouted is a partisan and emotional situation that goes nowhere and doesn't create a solution, a true solution comes from compromise. The 2nd Amendment is part of the Bill of Rights, anything removed from that part of the Constitution would set a precedent for modifying other parts of those scared rights, including the 1st. The likeliness of it being removed is nil, so take that off the table. A licensing system would be a good compromise, and while one shouldn't have to pay to exercise a right, we need a solution that doesn't punish people who did nothing wrong.

Even that is only a temporary solution, violence will only be curbed, not stopped. Again, we to travel to those darker parts of our mind to find a solution. When we look into the eyes of these criminals, do we not just fear them for their actions, but do we also fear them because we fear we may also be capable of the same thing? The vast majority of us have a moral code, we think about doing something bad, but that little voice in our head tells us, that is wrong. This code may vary from person to person, but the basic concept is there. Without it, we're no different than animals, acting on impulse rather than reason.

We are also the sum of our experiences, and those experiences influence how we react to situations, they influence that internal moral code. If someone commits a crime and you look at their background, you'll probably be able to trace back and figure out why they committed that crime, what influenced them.

Trying to improve education, helping people out of poverty, prison reform, and greater awareness of mental heath, along side curbing the sale of illegal firearms are solutions, but not one that is 100%.

The unfortunate truth is, even we come to an understanding of those darker places, we won't even have a full solution to the problem. Humans are unpredictable creatures and we can not calculate how each individual person will turnout. That is not to say we should just give up, that would be foolish. But for us to go on blaming inanimate objects, even guns, is also foolish. We're just putting a bandaid over a scapegoat so that we feel better. We need to look at out culture and assess if what we're doing is right, and maybe then, we'll find a solution.

Tuesday, October 3, 2017

An Apology for my Comments

Yesterday was a whirlwind of emotion for everyone, one of the worst shootings in American history. When I see a disaster happen, I will always look for the truth, and try to assess the situation to it's fullest, however I am subject to the emotions caused by and my political leanings, as much as I try to curb.

My apology is for those who were offended to my reactions to an Onion article posted by "Star Trek". actor Will Wheaton. The article (linked below) entitled "‘No Way To Prevent This,’ Says Only Nation Where This Regularly Happens", uses the same text four times with changes in image and names in the text.

To me, the Onion, is a news site used for humor, not for real news and political commentary. To me, it appeared insulting to use one of their articles during a tragedy (this is the site that posted pieces on Biden selling Pot and Tim Kaine shoving crackers into a voting machine). The addition of blaming the NRA (who I've seen yet to even issue a statement or mentioned in the Onion piece) by saying "Fuck the NRA" just seemed like unwarranted attack, even against a group I don't support.

My response to this is not in keeping with my own personal rules on discussing politics and lowered myself to the level the troll. It also is not in keeping with the message of this blog, which is to provide my opinions in an eloquent manor and promote intelligent civil discourse.

Again, I apologize, my comments were offensive, and,I was error in my interpretation of the article; I have since deleted those posts.

Thank you.

Link:
http://www.theonion.com/article/no-way-to-prevent-this-says-only-nation-where-this-36131

Friday, August 18, 2017

Ripples of the Civil War

I don't need to rehash the events that occurred in Charlottesville Virginia these weekend, as it should still be fresh in everyones mind. The worst parts of this country ripping at very fabric of the nation. I blame both the left and the right for the altercations that have occurred since the election. In this case however, Alt-Right White Supremacists are by far the most to blame.

What we are feeling to day are the ripple effects of the Civil War, probably the most prolific war in American history. For five years, 1861 to 1865, we tore ourselves over slavery. It has been argued that "States Rights" were a major cause of the war, and there is truth in that, but slavery was the primary reason it was fought. The affects of the war reverberate to the modern day, it reshaped out culture and who we are today.

Following the end of the Civil War came a short lived period known as Reconstruction, Lincoln's plan to bring the South back into the Union. The purpose of Reconstruction was to rebuild the Southern infrastructure and economy, and protect the rights of freed slaves. The South was divided in large military districts to help facilitate this effort. However, when it ended in 1877, racist sentiment still existed and rights of African-Americans were still curtailed and that wouldn't be full addressed until close to a hundred years later in the 1960s. It was also during that time, many of the Confederate statues that are the center of the current controversy were built.

When I first heard about the removal of the Confederate statues, I was irritated by it. As a proponent of studying History as unbiased as possible, and heavily against revisionist historians, I found the idea of tearing down these monuments as repugnant. It looked like plot from the left to rewrite our history that was comfortable with their sensibilities. After some arguments, soul searching, research, and events of this weekend, I am behind taking Confederate monuments down.

To be clear, however, this does not include museums, they are places of learning, and must look history as unbiased as possible. I had a long conversation on Twitter concerning this, we need to preserve history, not bury it due to people's sensitivities.

Back to the issue at hand, the statues the commemorate the Confederate cause should be taken down. As I said, slavery was the main cause of the war, this was a rebellion to keep that institution intact. We shouldn't be celebrating people who fought to keep this crime alive. Many of these statues were built following the end of reconstruction as a way to legitimize the Confederate cause, they were constructed even as recent as the 1930s.

In response to the calls to have the Confederate statues removed, many right leaning groups have posted memes asking why statues of FDR aren't being torn down because of the Japanese interment camps during World War II. While some left leaning groups have called for the removal of of the Theodore Roosevelt statues in New York and even blowing up Mount Rushmore. That is a loss of focus on issue at hand, we're talking racism and prejudice here and people threw the nation into war to keep those beliefs. I'm not sure how many times I need to repeat that.

To conclude, this nation needs to do some soul searching. The comments of President Trump represent a nation that still believes (to a good extent) in the myth of the south and not the truth. They are offensive and inappropriate if they to finally leave the Civil War in the past and learn the lessons from it instead of being doomed to repeat it.


Additional Reading:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reconstruction_Era

https://www.dallasnews.com/opinion/commentary/2017/08/10/attended-1936-dedication-robert-e-lee-memorial-dallas

https://www.romper.com/p/what-is-antifa-the-anti-fascist-protestors-are-being-blamed-for-violence-in-charlottesville-76857

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unite_the_Right_rally

http://www.breitbart.com/big-government/2017/08/17/vice-editor-lets-blow-mount-rushmore/